J'ai lu les explications sur le design de Nadu,
ici.
Je vous cite le passage intéressant:
So, how did we get here?
Nadu went through almost all of Modern Horizons 3's development looking something like this:
Nadu, Winged Wisdom
1GU
Legendary Creature – Bird Wizard
3/4
Flying
You may cast permanent spells as though they had flash.
Whenever a permanent you control becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land card, put it onto the battlefield. Otherwise, put it into your hand.
Nadu was a powerful option against interaction and a part of various Bant midrange strategies throughout our testing, but it wasn't something that our group perceived as much more than a role player.
For some more context, Modern Horizons testing works differently than typical Standard FFL (Future Future League). For both Modern Horizons 2 and Modern Horizons 3, we brought in a small group of contractors and worked on the set in a dedicated sprint as a collaboration between that group and a small number of play designers. The playtesting time is more dense, as the group is singularly focused on the set without other responsibilities, but shorter in terms of weeks.
After the playtesting, there were a series of last-minute checks of the sets by various groups. This is the normal operating procedure for every release. It is a series of opportunities for folks from various departments and disciplines to weigh in on every component of the project and give final feedback.
In one of these meetings, there was a great deal of concern raised by Nadu's flash-granting ability for Commander play. After removing the ability, it wasn't clear that the card would have an audience or a home, something that is important for every card we make. Ultimately, my intention was to create a build-around aimed at Commander play, which resulted in the final text.
I missed the interaction with zero-mana abilities that are so problematic. The last round of folks who were shown the card in the building missed it too. We didn't playtest with Nadu's final iteration, as we were too far along in the process, and it shipped as-is.
I want to go over some talking points and learnings, but before I do, I'll emphasize that, despite the failings in process, ultimately the card was my responsibility as the lead designer of the set.
On dirait littéralement un stagiaire qui n'a quasiment jamais touché au jeu.
Faut pas s'étonner si c'est le bordel dans tous les formats.
Dans le passage en gras, le gars admet ouvertement qu'il design des cartes pour le commander dans un format modern, qu'il a fait la modif au dernier moment dans un set plus puissant et donc plus risqué. Qu'ils ont pas testé, et qu'après avoir retiré: le "que vos adversaires contrôlent", il s'est pas dit qu'on pouvait cibler ses propres créatures?
Il faut aussi qu'ils arrêtent de justifier leurs erreurs sur un manque de "playtesting", y a pas besoin de tester Nadu pour comprendre que cette carte est débile, et y en a pas un dans leur équipe qui s'en est rendu compte.
C'est plus un problème d'organisation là, c'est un problème de compétences.
C'est juste scandaleux.